Promoted to manager without training? A guide for new public-sector managers
Kathryn Williams
·
8 minute read
Being promoted into management is a big achievement. It usually means your organisation trusts your experience, recognises your contribution and believes you're ready for more responsibility.
But what happens when you're suddenly responsible for managing people, handling difficult conversations and making decisions – without ever having been taught how to do any of it?
It's a situation many public-sector professionals find themselves in.
You might have been an experienced policy officer, project manager, administrator or subject-matter expert. You've built up years of knowledge, delivered excellent work and become someone colleagues rely on. Then, almost overnight, your role changes. You're no longer just responsible for your own work. You're responsible for helping other people succeed, too.
And that's a very different skill set.
Whether you've recently stepped into your first management position or have found yourself managing a team without formal training, you're not alone. Here's what every new public-sector manager should know about making the transition successfully.

The rise of the 'accidental manager'
Not everyone sets out to become a manager. Sometimes, it's simply the next step in a career.
An employee consistently performs well, develops specialist knowledge or demonstrates strong technical ability. When a management position becomes available, they're the obvious choice.
But being good at your job doesn't automatically mean you'll know how to manage other people.
This is sometimes referred to as becoming an 'accidental manager' – someone who moves into a management position without receiving formal training in leadership or people management.
And it's more common than you might think.
Research by the Chartered Management Institute (CMI), published in its 2023 Taking Responsibility: Why UK PLC Needs Better Managers report, found that 82% of managers had entered management positions without any formal management and leadership training.
The research also found that 52% of managers did not hold any management or leadership qualifications.
These findings highlight a significant gap between promoting people into management positions and giving them the skills they need to succeed.
For public-sector organisations, where managers often balance demanding workloads, limited resources, complex responsibilities and the needs of diverse teams, that gap matters.
Discover ModernGov's Leadership & Management Training
Why is managing people so different from doing the job yourself?
One of the biggest challenges of becoming a manager is realising that the skills that made you successful in your previous role aren't necessarily the same skills you'll need now.
As an individual contributor, success might have meant completing projects, producing accurate reports, meeting deadlines or solving problems independently.
As a manager, your success increasingly depends on how well you enable other people to do those things.
That means learning to:
- Delegate work rather than taking everything on yourself.
- Motivate people with different personalities and working styles.
- Give constructive feedback and address performance concerns.
- Manage competing priorities across a team.
- Resolve disagreements and handle difficult conversations.
- Support employee development and wellbeing.
- Communicate expectations clearly and consistently.
It's a considerable shift.
Many new managers also struggle with the feeling that they should already know what they're doing. After all, they've been promoted because they're good at their job.
But management isn't something you automatically learn through experience in another role. It requires its own set of skills, knowledge and practice.
You might like: Why is Delegation Important for Effective Leadership? 5 Key Reasons
6 essential skills every new public-sector manager needs
So, what should you focus on when stepping into your first management position?
Here are six areas that can make a real difference.
1. Delegation: Learning to let go
If you've spent years being the person who gets things done, handing responsibility to someone else can feel uncomfortable.
You might worry that the work won't be completed to the same standard, take longer than expected or create more problems than simply doing it yourself.
But effective delegation isn't about passing unwanted tasks to other people. It's about giving employees responsibility, helping them develop and making better use of the team's collective skills.
Start by being clear about the outcome you expect, agreeing deadlines and making sure the person has the information and resources they need.
Then give them space to get on with it.
Resist the temptation to check every small detail or take the task back at the first sign of difficulty. People need opportunities to learn, make decisions and build confidence.
Remember: If you're doing everyone's work, when are you finding the time to manage?
2. Communication: Making expectations clear
Good communication is at the heart of effective management.
Your team needs to understand what's expected of them, why their work matters and where to turn when they need support.
This sounds straightforward, but communication becomes more complicated when you're managing different personalities, working styles and levels of experience.
For new managers, it's important to develop the confidence to:
- Set clear expectations and explain responsibilities.
- Listen actively rather than simply waiting to respond.
- Give feedback that is constructive and specific.
- Adapt your communication style to different individuals.
- Keep people informed when priorities or plans change.
It's also worth remembering that communication isn't just about what you say. Making time to listen, asking questions and being approachable can make a significant difference to how supported your team feels.
Discover our communication & engagement training courses
3. Managing former colleagues: Navigating a change in relationships
One of the trickiest situations for a first-time manager is being promoted within your existing team.
Yesterday, you were working alongside your colleagues. Today, you're responsible for managing them.
It can feel awkward, particularly if you're now expected to delegate tasks, address performance issues or make decisions that affect people you previously considered peers.
Some colleagues may be completely supportive, while others might take time to adjust to the new arrangement.
The key is to establish professional boundaries without becoming distant or overly authoritative.
Be open about the change in your responsibilities, treat everyone consistently and avoid feeling that you need to prove yourself by becoming overly strict.
You don't need to stop being friendly with former colleagues. You do, however, need to recognise that your responsibilities have changed.
4. Giving feedback and handling difficult conversations
Few new managers look forward to difficult conversations.
Whether you're addressing missed deadlines, poor performance, disagreements or changes in behaviour, knowing how to approach sensitive situations is an essential management skill.
Avoiding these conversations might feel easier in the short term, but problems rarely disappear on their own.
The longer an issue is left unresolved, the more difficult it can become.
A good starting point is to:
- Address concerns promptly rather than allowing frustration to build.
- Focus on specific behaviours or situations, not personal criticism.
- Give the other person an opportunity to explain their perspective.
- Listen without becoming defensive.
- Agree on practical next steps and follow up afterwards.
Remember that difficult conversations don't have to become confrontational. Approaching them with empathy, preparation and a clear purpose can help everyone move forward.
Discover our Handling Difficult Conversations training course
5. Motivating and developing your team
A promotion doesn't automatically make you an inspiring leader.
People are motivated by different things. Some value recognition, others want more responsibility, while some are looking for opportunities to develop new skills or progress their careers.
Getting to know your team as individuals is an important part of effective management.
Make time for regular one-to-ones, ask people about their ambitions and find out what support they need to perform at their best.
It's also important to recognise good work. Acknowledging someone's contribution, offering constructive encouragement or giving them the opportunity to take ownership of a project can go a long way.
You don't need to have all the answers. Sometimes, being a good manager simply means helping someone find their own.
Discover our Developing a Positive Team Culture trainining course
6. Prioritisation: Managing your own workload while supporting others
One of the biggest surprises for new managers is just how much of their time gets taken up by other people's work.
Suddenly, your calendar is filled with meetings, one-to-ones, questions, approvals and unexpected problems.
It's easy to spend the entire day reacting to requests, leaving your own responsibilities until the end of the afternoon.
The challenge is learning to balance your management responsibilities with your existing workload.
Try to:
- Identify which tasks genuinely need your attention.
- Distinguish between urgent and important work.
- Set aside dedicated time for planning and team development.
- Avoid becoming the default person for every small decision.
- Encourage employees to solve problems independently where appropriate.
Being busy isn't necessarily the same as being productive. Effective managers make time to focus on the things that will have the greatest impact on their team.
You might like our: A Guide to Project Management training course
What happens when managers don't receive the right training?
Management development isn't just about helping individuals feel more confident in their new roles. It can also have a wider impact on employee experience and organisational performance.
When managers lack the skills to communicate effectively, support their teams or address problems, the consequences can extend beyond their own workload.
Employees may feel undervalued, unclear about expectations or reluctant to raise concerns.
The CMI's 2023 research highlighted just how significant this can be. Among employees who considered their manager ineffective, 50% said they planned to leave their organisation within the next 12 months. This compared with 21% of employees who rated their manager as effective.
It's an important reminder that management quality can influence how people feel about their workplace and whether they choose to stay.
There is also evidence that structured development can make a difference.
In October 2024, Government Skills reported that 81% of civil servants who had completed its Line Manager Induction Programme felt very or extremely confident that they understood their responsibilities as a line manager.
More than 4,300 civil servants had completed the programme since its introduction in November 2023.
The findings demonstrate the value of giving new managers the opportunity to understand their responsibilities and develop the confidence to carry them out.
Sources: CMI, Taking Responsibility: Why UK PLC Needs Better Managers (2023); Government Skills, Induction programme boosts line managers' confidence (2024).
You might like: What Leadership Skills Do Public Sector Managers Need in 2026?
How can organisations better support first-time managers?
It's easy to assume that employees will work out management as they go along. After all, many experienced managers have learned through trial and error.
But leaving people to figure everything out independently isn't necessarily the best approach.
Organisations have an important role to play in preparing employees for management responsibilities, particularly when promoting people from specialist or technical positions.
Here are four ways to provide better support.
1. Introduce management training before or shortly after promotion
Don't wait until someone is struggling to provide development opportunities. Give new managers the foundations they need early on, covering communication, delegation, performance management and leadership.
2. Provide ongoing support and mentoring
Training is a starting point, not a one-off solution. Encourage new managers to learn from experienced colleagues, share challenges and ask questions without feeling judged.
3. Create opportunities to practise new skills
Understanding a management technique is one thing. Feeling confident enough to use it in a real situation is another. Role-play, practical exercises and scenario-based learning can help managers put their knowledge into practice.
4. Recognise that management is a skill that needs developing
Even experienced managers face new challenges. Changes in working practices, employee expectations and organisational priorities mean leadership development should be an ongoing investment.
Ultimately, good managers aren't simply born with the right skills. They need the opportunity to develop them.
Frequently asked questions about first-time manager training
What is an accidental manager?
An accidental manager is someone who moves into a management position without receiving formal management or leadership training. They may have been promoted because of their technical knowledge, experience or performance in a previous role, rather than their people management skills.
What training should a first-time manager receive?
First-time managers should develop practical skills in communication, delegation, giving feedback, managing performance, resolving conflict, motivating employees and prioritising workloads. Leadership training should also help managers understand their responsibilities and build confidence in leading others.
How do you manage a team when you've never been a manager before?
Start by building relationships with your team, setting clear expectations and understanding individual responsibilities. Make time for regular conversations, learn to delegate and don't be afraid to ask for guidance. Management is a learning process, and seeking support is a strength rather than a weakness.
Why is management training important in the public sector?
Public-sector managers often work in complex environments, balancing service delivery, employee wellbeing, organisational priorities and limited resources. Management training helps them develop the skills to support their teams, communicate effectively and manage challenges with confidence.
When should someone receive first-time manager training?
Ideally, employees should receive management development before taking on their first management position or shortly after being promoted. Early training can help them understand their responsibilities and avoid developing unhelpful habits through trial and error.
Give your new managers the confidence to lead
Being promoted into management should be an exciting step in someone's career, not a case of being handed a new job and left to work everything out alone.
Whether someone is managing a team for the first time, navigating the transition from colleague to manager or developing their existing leadership approach, the right training can make a meaningful difference.
At ModernGov, we deliver practical leadership and management training designed around the challenges public-sector professionals face.
From first-time manager development and effective delegation to communication, performance management and handling difficult conversations, our courses help managers build the confidence and skills to lead effectively.
Looking to support new managers in your organisation?
We can tailor training to your team's experience, responsibilities and development needs, whether you're supporting a small group of newly promoted managers or developing leadership capability across your organisation.
Explore our Leadership and Management training or contact inhouse@moderngov.com to discuss your requirements.